Mr. White
- Wants
- At first, obtain a modest sum; later, avoid what he fears the next wish might bring.
- Chooses
- Makes the money wish, reluctantly wishes his son alive, then uses the last wish without its wording being disclosed.
They ask for two hundred pounds. How will the money arrive?
The White family is told that the monkey’s paw can grant wishes, with disturbing consequences. Mr. White asks for two hundred pounds.
YOUR TURN, IF YOU FEEL LIKE IT
How would you write it?
How could the money arrive through an ordinary event that makes the wish horrifying? Keep the requested amount exact and the chain of cause and effect plausible.
SPOILERS AHEADSee the original design & why it works
WHAT HAPPENS IN THE WORKTHE DESIGN, TAKEN APART TAKE IT TO YOUR OWN PAGE
A representative of Herbert’s employer reports that he has died in machinery. The company offers the family two hundred pounds. The amount matches the wish, while the story leaves room to question whether the events are supernatural or coincidental.
Give them the exact result through a route that destroys what they hoped it would improve.
CueShelf’s reading of the choices that make this story work.
Mrs. White
- Wants
- After Herbert’s death, have her son back.
- Chooses
- Urges the second wish and tries to open the door when the knocking begins.
Where the conflict lives
A small improvement to family life is followed by a loss that makes the money worthless to them. Later, the parents share their grief but disagree about whether the possible return should be welcomed.
Who knows what — and when
The amount of compensation exactly matches the wish. That supports a sinister reading, but neither the visitor nor the ending proves supernatural causation or identifies whoever is outside.
How the design unfolds
Choose an ordinary desire
Mr. White asks for two hundred pounds after Herbert suggests the sum would clear the house.
Use a plausible route
The employer’s visitor reports Herbert’s fatal accident before explaining the compensation.
Let one detail connect the events
The offered sum is two hundred pounds. The match makes the earlier wish horrifying.
Turn grief into a new choice
Another wish and the knocking divide the parents. After the last wish, the knocking stops; its words and the visitor’s identity remain unrevealed.
Works when…
- The desired outcome must be precise enough for its later arrival to be recognized.
- The cost must damage the purpose of the wish, not simply add an unrelated punishment.
Watch for…
- Do not explain the paw as a proven malicious agent; the original leaves causation open.
- If the story relies on uncertainty, showing the visitor at the door or spelling out the last wish changes the mechanism.
An original variation
Independent example: a neighborhood receives the exact grant needed to repair its rehearsal hall, but the contract requires ticket prices its regular musicians cannot afford. Establish the funding condition before acceptance. Write one organizer ready to sign and another asking whose use of the hall they are preserving.
Your writing exercise
Name a small desired result and why it matters. Choose an ordinary process that can deliver it at that purpose's expense. Write the arrival of the news, saving the exact matching detail until late in the scene. End with two affected people choosing different next actions. Decide whether causation is proved or remains uncertain.
Check the original: 3 reading notes
These are plot observations in our words. The locations below help you check them in the linked edition.
- Part I: Sergeant-Major Morris’s account and the first wish after his departure.
Morris describes three wishes for each of three men. Herbert suggests two hundred pounds, and Mr. White wishes for that amount.
- Part II: the employer’s visitor, from the accident report to the final amount.
The visitor reports the machinery accident and offers two hundred pounds as compensation.
- Part III: the second wish, the knocking, and the final paragraph before the ebook end marker.
Mrs. White tries to open the door; Mr. White makes a final wish whose words are not reported. The door opens onto an empty road.
Do not reduce this to “every wish is punished.” The useful design question is which causal route turns success into a particular loss. This example discusses a death.
The Monkey’s Paw, Part I (the first wish) and Part II (the employer’s visitor).
Read the source at www.gutenberg.org ↗
The design study includes its source evidence, community references and adaptation license. Observations are paraphrased; no original artwork is reproduced.
TAKE A NEW DIRECTION